Delphy you just listed all the additional features of vB that I don't think I used.
But I wasn't staff, so my opinion doesn't mean much.
About the only interesting thing for me on the 3.7+ releases is the social groups system - and even then I wouldn't do it in the way they did it. Profile customisations are something I had on MTS2 for longer than they had them in the base code, albeit in a different manner.
The other stuff (friends, and so on) are stuff that is important in a "social" aspect but I think most "community" sites would be just fine without it.
If we break down Insim in terms of actual features what we are left with is the following:
- A front page which looks like a standard CMS type system
- The actual forums which really aren't any different from any normal forums
- Some other "nifty" things like the groups/notifications which I daresay hardly anybody used in comparison to the total site usage
There is no specialised download view, nothing special about actually *looking* for downloads, no specialised story view like we have on S2C. Heck, pretty much the entire site is just a standard forum with a whole mish-mash of different content and none of it is really customised or optimised to work *well* with what it's presenting.
It would be great if:
- Downloads could be sorted/filtered/showed in a paginated form across the whole site, much like MTS2 does, but keep the creator-centric forum structure for those old-skool views and the creators ego.
- Stories could be shown in a specialised story view, much like S2C, for easy story reading.
- The downloads themselves had keywords or tags and EP requirements etc that are common everywhere
All of this could be done in an SMF system and could then be used on other Sims 2 sites as well since a lot of them use SMF.
Ultimately though I guess it's up to the staff and the ex members as to what they want to see and use.