PMBD

The Pirate Ship => ARR! => Topic started by: Lhop on 2007 July 11, 02:05:44



Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 11, 02:05:44
Pardon me if someone has already posted this, but I saw this and just got so fucking pissed.
I was at Pandora Sims 2, and I looked at the "Super Mod" and it is all hacks from MATY.  They even kept the name and description, just took out all of the MATY stuff.  Here's the link if anyone is interested in checking it out.
Pandora Sims Asswipes (http://www.pandorasims.net/sim2nm.html)
The thing that pisses me off most?  They are charging for this.  That's right, it's a payfile.  I hate these assholes.  I was looking at their site, and it has a Job Opportunities section, and it describes one of the animation jobs as "high paying".  i thought these sites were only charging to help with bandwidth.
I am going to send these idiots a message about the "Super Mod" and see if they deny it.  This bothers me a lot because some poor schmuck could get conned into paying for this, not knowing they can get the same thing free from the people who ACTUALLY MADE IT.  Not only that, but they'll be able to get any necessary fixes, etc.  I highly doubt that this site offers any type of support...
After I write the message, i will post a copy of it, and I will let you know if I get a reply.
FUCK!
Sorry, I think I am wayyy too pissed off about this.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Feverish on 2007 July 11, 02:14:24
I think this has been mentioned somewhere in another thread.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: mando on 2007 July 11, 02:15:52
Yep, I'm pretty sure this has already been covered (it's still lame though). I'd direct you to the thread, but I can't quite remember where it is (lost in the mists of time, I suppose). Someone else might be better able to direct you if they can dig it up.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Yaardarm Monkey on 2007 July 11, 02:16:58
I dont think we can have enough
"Blade from PandoraSims is a crusty butthole" threads

 :twisted:     :lol:     :twisted:


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Bigtruckgirl on 2007 July 11, 02:52:57
http://phorum.mustnotbenamed.com/viewtopic.php?t=833&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=30

Towards the bottom of the page someone asks why the MATY stuff is in the booty, next page says it may be a poke at Pandora's.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 11, 02:55:30
Meh, okay, either way, I sent them an email, if you're interested.  I just was really surprised at this, but I don't know why I am getting surprised at the greed of a paysite.
Oh well, maybe I'll get an interesting reply.  Sorry for posting on this when someone already had posted...I just was pretty sure I hadn't seen anything on it.  I guess that's what I get for thinking I had found something new and shocking!  :D  :lol:

I sent them an email, here it is:


To: bladex@pandorasims.net

Subject: pandora sims enquiry

Dear Bladex,
I am writing in regards to your "Super Mod".
    I do not know if you are aware of this, but your super mod consists entirely of other people's mods, namely those of MATY (More Awesome Than You).You are offering this "Super Mod" for purchase, but these mods were made freely available to your site and the community by MATY.  I am writing as a member of the MATY forum and on behalf of the PMBD (Paysites Must Be Destroyed) forum.
    I think that it would be a nice gesture of goodwill if you were to give a link to MATY, and let your site visitors know that they can get these mods for free over at MATY if they choose to.  I hope you will consider doing this, or taking the Super Mod down and telling your visitors to go to MATY for this.
    I would appreciate a reply about this, you can contact me via this email address.  Thank you in advance.
Thank you,
Lisa

If you would like to write them too, make sure to copy my subject line, I copied it from their site, they said not to change it becasue if you do the spam blocker might block it.
Hopefully I will get a reply from someone and something will be done about this, I think the least they could do is to put a link on their site to MATY.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: liegenschonheit on 2007 July 11, 06:02:38
Fat chance of that. Blade just steals whatever he likes and charges for it. Pescado and MATY aren't the only ones he's done this to, and he pretty much told Numenor to shove it when he asked that his creations be removed from a pay site.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Duckie on 2007 July 11, 07:57:53
Yep, it was discussed. I saw it over on Pandora Sims site and it made me wonder if it was the same set of hacks. Off to MATY I went to find out that it is the same set of hacks, they already knew about it, and were laughing at it. Shortly thereafter the MATY stuff popped up in the booty. There wasn't a loud to-do made of it so that's probably why it was new to you.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 11, 09:24:50
Quote from: "liegenschonheit"
Fat chance of that. Blade just steals whatever he likes and charges for it. Pescado and MATY aren't the only ones he's done this to, and he pretty much told Numenor to shove it when he asked that his creations be removed from a pay site.


Hmm, I guess you were right, because this is the response I got from s/h/it:

they are stealing my stuff so I'm doing the same

No greeting, salutation, capitalization or punctuation.  Then again, I guess maybe I was expecting too much out of someone who has usable vibrators for sims on their site...Not that I have anything wrong with usable vibrators for sims, but you know what I mean...
Should I write back, because I know s/h/it's saying that PMBD stole their shit, but they aren't using PMBD's hacks, they're using MATY's hacks.  Then again, they probably see it as being interchangeable, and I guess it sort of is.  Wow, I am bummed out though, I at least thought they would be, well, I don't know, different about this.
Again, that's what I get for having too much faith in humanity.

*Edited to fix stupid typos


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Randomness on 2007 July 11, 09:27:43
So apparently that idiot thinks that downloading anything on the net (even if it's freely offered) is 'stealing.'  :shock:   Wow.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Duckie on 2007 July 11, 09:47:38
Quote from: "lhop"
Hmm, I guess you were right, because this is the response I got from s/h/it:

they are stealing my stuff so I'm doing the same


And yet we haven't stolen one single thing from PandoraSims. It's all been paid for.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: washout on 2007 July 11, 13:20:44
There was a thread in S2C where numenor posted his exchange with him, making the guy look like a total ass. However, he was threatened because he told him that he'd take them down as long as he didn't post the conversation on MTS2. (and he didn't  :lol:)
As if his reputation isn't ruined enough...


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Alphess on 2007 July 11, 13:35:42
Quote from: "washout"
There was a thread in S2C where numenor posted his exchange with him, making the guy look like a total ass. However, he was threatened because he told him that he'd take them down as long as he didn't post the conversation on MTS2. (and he didn't  :lol:)
As if his reputation isn't ruined enough...


http://forums.sims2community.com/showthread.php?t=23345

Here's that thread...


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Jaida on 2007 July 11, 16:31:39
Quote from: "evilredduckie"
And yet we haven't stolen one single thing from PandoraSims. It's all been paid for.



I bet considers it stealing. ;) Perhaps MATY should only have members download like what MTS2 and inSim do now. That is if Pescado cares about it or will just exploit the douche bag worse than Numenor did.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Zazazu on 2007 July 11, 18:07:02
One could go to EA as did the creators who had left TSR. Just thinking. You've got a paysite stealing free files, selling them, and of course they are EA's package format.

I know from when it was discussed at MATY recently that Pes didn't truly really care...they don't keep the things updated like he does on the site. Let them deal with the whining when stuff conflicts.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: liegenschonheit on 2007 July 11, 18:33:43
Well, to be honest I don't think that as pirates, we can really complain too much if someone hosts our files on other sites. After all, isn't the basis of our argument that EA has given us permission to freely share all files as we wish? In that case, Blade has every right to host MATY hacks on his site, just as we have every right to host pay files here. BUT as pirates, we still agree that credit should in every case be given to the original creator. Every creator, every time. It isn't stated in the EULA, but it's common courtesy, right? And it doesn't need to be said that we don't agree whatsoever with free files being posted in a pay section.

So I can only conclude one thing, Blade is a douchebag who thinks that by hosting Pescado's hacks, refusing to credit him and charging for it that he will piss people off. It is working, I guess, except not on the intended target. Pescado probably doesn't give a rats ass, and if people are dumb enough to pay for them elsewhere then I guess we can't save everyone.

Also Blade, if you do read this, I just want you to know that your files are in the booty for the sake of completeness. No one really wants em, they're right on par with the Carla Niven stuff. Pandora Sims peaked in TS1 days, since then it's just another ugly stepchild with subpar downloads.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Hecubus on 2007 July 11, 20:26:30
What Leigen said.

All of it.

(I"d blame her for stealing my thunder, but mine was barely a rumble compared to her eloquence. Oh, and we toss Pandora around the pirate crew like a hot potato...no one wants to do it.)


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Jaida on 2007 July 11, 22:28:46
What's next? He steals the inSimenator? :lol:


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Feverish on 2007 July 11, 23:00:57
Didn't someone already steal the inSimenator? I could have sworn I read that in one of the threads.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lorelei on 2007 July 12, 01:53:18
Pes has, I believe, stated that he honestly doesn't care.

I suspect that, if he ever thinks much about it at all, he's not thrilled that this stuff is being sold, but pretty much seems to think that if anyone is dumb enough to pay for outdated custom content that is available for free and supported / updated elsewhere, then that is on the dumb person's head.

If I have misinterpreted Pes's comments, that is on me. He was asked directly and his attitude was basically "Meh, whatever". :)


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Randomness on 2007 July 12, 02:59:20
Quote from: "Feverish"
Didn't someone already steal the inSimenator? I could have sworn I read that in one of the threads.


Someone plagiarized it, yes; as in, they downloaded it for free and then attempted to sell it. You can't really steal something that's offered for free, can you? You can, however, attempt to take credit for creating it and try to sell it in an immoral fashion (which was done).


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Jaida on 2007 July 12, 14:26:10
Quote from: "Feverish"
Didn't someone already steal the inSimenator? I could have sworn I read that in one of the threads.



Yes but not Bladex from PandoraSims.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 17, 10:17:53
I know I am a bit late in replying, but I wanted to reply again, since I originally posted this thread.
I agree with what Liegenschonheit said, and I didn't realize that Pescado doesn't care.  Although he is not required to credit Pescado, he should.
Having said that, I think that he should at least give credit where credit is due, since we do that here, and we are seen as being the scum of the sims community by many (wrongfully, but it's true) so shouldn't he at least try to live up to the standards of a bunch of "Pirates"?  I suppose he doesn't have to, so he won't.  He is a scumbag, and as Liegenschonheit said, a douchebag.
He seems like a scummy loser, and usually there is no talking to such people, which is why I didn't reply to his reply.
While EA does allow for sharing, they don't allow for profitting off of CC or hacks.  And if this was a free site doing this, I wouldn't have mentioned it, but it is a pay site selling free items without credit, and as has been mentioned by me and someone else in this thread, he is selling people unsupported versions of hacks that he does not update, and I think that behavior is unconscionable.
All in the name of the almighty dollar, though, I suppose.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 17, 10:18:01
*edited to delete stupid double post*


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 17, 11:29:37
Quote
I know I am a bit late in replying, but I wanted to reply again, since I originally posted this thread.


And again and again and again............................ apparently  :lol:


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 17, 13:50:07
Heh, calalily.  :shock:
Yes, I suppose I am beating a dead horse a bit here, but I tend to do that.

I will take the hint and not post on this unless I am directly asked something.  I only wanted to post because I had said that I might email him again, and I wanted to let people know that I had decided against it for the reasons mentioned above.
Plus I am very talkative.   :lol:

ETA:
OOOPS!  I did it again, didn't I?   :oops:    :lol:


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Captain Feathersword on 2007 July 17, 14:39:54
I think Cala was referring to your double post.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Jojoba on 2007 July 17, 15:13:35
lhop, she was talking about your double post, ya plum ;) *passes bottle of rum*


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 17, 17:43:44
Oh shit, she was, wasn't she?!  I just noticed that.
Sorry guys, it was like 4 am when I wrote that and I hadn't gone to sleep yet.   :oops:
Either way, I should probably just drop this, since nothing will come of this anyhow.
But, I stand by what I said Blade or Bladex, whatever the fuck he calls himself, is scum!

ETA:
*Drinks rum, even though she shouldn't because she is already quite flaky today*

*Edited again to fix a stupid typo*


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 17, 17:48:57
Yes I was referring to the double post - but I tend to write too formally so I sound flat of affect and mean I should use smilies moar.  :lol:


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Lhop on 2007 July 17, 17:53:34
Calalily, I don't think you came off as mean, I think you came off as being right, and when you're right, you're right.  I saw the smily you put in, and saw it as you teasing me for bringing up something again just to state my opinion on it, that I had already stated, without really saying anything other than saying I wouldn't email him again.
I think you came off fine, it was just my dumb mistake for not realizing that I double posted.  Also, you made me notice that I was doing something dumb without actually calling me on it.

No hard feelings though.  But I should probably SLEEP MOAR before posting!   :wink:  :D


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 17, 18:19:14
Quote from: "Lhop"
Calalily, I don't think you came off as mean, I think you came off as being right, and when you're right, you're right.  I saw the smily you put in, and saw it as you teasing me for bringing up something again just to state my opinion on it, that I had already stated, without really saying anything other than saying I wouldn't email him again.
I think you came off fine, it was just my dumb mistake for not realizing that I double posted.  Also, you made me notice that I was doing something dumb without actually calling me on it.

No hard feelings though.  But I should probably SLEEP MOAR before posting!   :wink:  :D


I are amazing. I didn't even read your post, just see the doublepost and teased you - but apparently I encouraged an epiphany.  Maybe I should has a cult?


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Duckie on 2007 July 17, 18:27:09
What would be the incentive to join your cult?


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 17, 18:31:15
Can I have eggs over-easy, bacon and toast with strawberry jam with my epiphany?


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 17, 18:32:52
Hmm....

I are amazing
I give epiphanies
I are amazing
That is all.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 17, 20:56:03
Talk about you have got to be kidding me... I was cruising the net, seeing some sites I've not been to for a long time and saw that Holy Simoly had a new donation set up... Ok, how in the hell did I miss the news about that? Am I suffering cranial/rectal displacement syndrome again or what? Cause I checked the booty, and sure enough our intrepid suppliers have been at it again. God, I need to keep a closer eye on the shit that goes on around me or I'm gonna wind up totally not aware that my son just tried to shove a blue crayon up my nose! Be right back, I need to go catch a heathen!

ETA that sometimes I gotta quit thinking before I type or shit goes in here that isn't what I was meaning to put... gah!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Skadi on 2007 July 20, 06:05:00
I knew Cal's ego would grow a cult sooner or later. Just glad it was sooner  :D

Pandora just plain sucks, worse than Carla Niven.


-Skadi, proud member of calalily's cult, must worship hairy face...


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 20, 06:26:16
Quote from: "Skadi"
I knew Cal's ego would grow a cult sooner or later. Just glad it was sooner  :D

Pandora just plain sucks, worse than Carla Niven.


-Skadi, proud member of calalily's cult, must worship hairy face...


 :D  I was going to just be a whore for the good stuff - webcams, Nouk hair, all kinds of goodies - but apparently:

I are amazing
I give epiphanies
I are amazing
That is all.

Anyway - shouldn't I be a member of your cult - giver of calalilysims?  :?


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Skadi on 2007 July 20, 07:27:04
No, I'm pretty sure I'm happy to be a cala-hairy cult member, my schedule is to full to lead one  :lol:

-Skadi


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 20, 07:58:03
Well, just so long as you have an epiphany every so often, the worship is pretty easy.

One sleep to HP!!!!!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Skadi on 2007 July 20, 08:26:56
Just to totally derail this, and on the subject of potter, has anyone seen this?
http://thefifthdistrict.com/potter/

-Skadi


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Ensign EO on 2007 July 20, 08:32:49
Are you trying to hypnotise me?

You can't convince me to join a cult that easily!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Skadi on 2007 July 20, 08:37:55
Sure we can!
potterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterweasleyweasley!

 :lol:

14hrs 27mins to go!

-Skadi


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 20, 08:48:14
Damn that thing hypnotises - I've been watching it for 4 minutes  :lol:

potterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterweasleyweasley!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Zazazu on 2007 July 20, 16:39:45
Just confirming, but I would be completely insane to go to a suburban Chicago bookstore tonight to wait for the midnight distribution, wouldn't I? I can't decide if I want to do that or wait until they open at 9 tomorrow. See, I have this tradition of getting them on the release day, reading them straight until done, and then waiting for everyone else to catch up. Usually not an issue, but my one best friend wants to go out for drinks for her birthday Saturday.

I had a dream that it was only 489 pages and I couldn't decide if I was pissed at the shortness or happy that I'd get it finished before her party-thing.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 20, 16:52:29
Quote from: "kariminger"
Just confirming, but I would be completely insane to go to a suburban Chicago bookstore tonight to wait for the midnight distribution, wouldn't I? I can't decide if I want to do that or wait until they open at 9 tomorrow. See, I have this tradition of getting them on the release day, reading them straight until done, and then waiting for everyone else to catch up. Usually not an issue, but my one best friend wants to go out for drinks for her birthday Saturday.

I had a dream that it was only 489 pages and I couldn't decide if I was pissed at the shortness or happy that I'd get it finished before her party-thing.


Not insane - smart - depends how well you want to do in Harry Potter internet stouches.  If I'm right with any of my theories I will be trouncing all over the Leaky Lounge telling them how right I was.

Woe to the Unbeliever will be my catch cry.

If however, I am wrong, I will drop off the face of the earth.

And no - I'm not a Harry/Hermione shipper - I'm not fucking mad.

My main theories are:
Snape loved Lily.
Harry will not die.
Horcruxes will be destroyed by Harry's blood - all immortalised under the name of calalily there too.

I'm going to bed in 10 minutes so I can be up and reading at 9.01am - Australians are soooo fucking lucky.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 20, 18:25:30
Oh, geeze, you guys are evil! My three year old is still listening to that damn thing... fuck, it's draining my brain and making me want to bake more stuff... Anything the child wants, falling under his spell with the influence of that damn thing in the background... I've already made oatmeal/raisin cookies and have a loaf of bread in the bread machine... The child will snack well...


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: AW on 2007 July 20, 18:39:06
Cookies?!?!  Can I have chocolate chip?


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: solianq on 2007 July 20, 19:02:09
I read the last chapter of an advance copy.  It was satisfying.  That is all.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 20, 19:28:35
Quote from: "armywife"
Cookies?!?!  Can I have chocolate chip?


*hands over plate of chocolate chip cookies* I made those Monday and still have some in the freezer cause I make double batches of those!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Skadi on 2007 July 20, 20:45:06
:cry:  me can't haz cookiez...

I went and had a tooth removed and it got messy, he was poking and pulling for an hour and I lost some bone as well. Until now I had never met a pain Pana Forte couldn't fix...

So I'm having chocolate mousse and waiting for potter!

2hrs 21 mins to go!

And my predictions are with you Cal, though I have been preparing myself for Snape's death, its okay because fanfic will resurrect him!

-Skadi
potterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterpotterweasleyweasley!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 20, 20:52:15
Evil! Eeeeeeevil! That Potter thing had my kid going for twenty goddamn minutes before he finally got bored with it and let me go elsewhere. And I'm jealous of anyone who gets the book tonight because if I know the millstone I married, I won't get to read it until next fucking year... But when your mouth heals, I'll givez ya cookiez, cus I is a cookie makin mommy... scary to think that the pirate you all love and think you know is actually domestic in some things... Like food!


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 20, 20:52:21
Fuck... double post and didn't mean to... where in the hell is the goddamn delete button on this stupid thing... gah...


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: AW on 2007 July 20, 21:39:14
*munches yummy chocolate chip cookies from pirate mommy...hands Paden rum since the monkey (actually she drank all of hers just doesn't want us to know) stole hers but I share because I got cookies*

Here's some rum for you too Skadi, sorry about your tooth..that sucks.  Hope you feel better soon.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Ieliminate on 2007 July 20, 21:53:20
The PotterPotter thing was hilarious, for the few seconds I watched it. I could believe a little kid watching it for hours. If it was later at night I probably have listened to it until I blanked out and exited it. I'm not getting it right away, I probably won't get it until Christmas. I'll probably read it before that though.

I've had enough cookies in the last two weeks to last for awhile.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Paden on 2007 July 20, 22:59:11
*hands Ieliminate a thick slice of Hawaiin sweet bread, still warm with honey butter on it* I don't only make cookies, ya know. And I love the cat avi's, those are awesome. My kid especially loved the kitty taking down the toilet paper because he saw my cat actually doing that...


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Aikane on 2007 July 21, 05:00:22
Well I've finished it :P I cried  :oops:

I don't know if I like it, the last four/five deaths were senseless you ask me.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 21, 15:03:42
All deaths by evil are senseless Aikane - I finished it 5 hours ago, and had a bit of a re-read of the bit on Hollows and Horcruxes and the Battle - don't want to say too much.  No one likes an unexpected spoiler.

I cried at least 5 times, and cried when the enormity hit me at the end of what had happened - mainly the names bit.

Although, I have to say Woe to the Unbeliever


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Aikane on 2007 July 21, 15:38:37
I know that, but there was no follow up or anything on them like there was with the deaths in previous books...it was just splat, dead and then nothing, straight into the epilouge. I would have liked a funeral or some sort of closing scene about the deaths.

(I howled continually through the book  :oops: Specially when *that* pair was killed - also trying to be ambiguous here - they were my favourites)

I was happy that one of my big theories was proved right though :D


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 21, 17:02:30
Quote from: "Aikane"
I know that, but there was no follow up or anything on them like there was with the deaths in previous books...it was just splat, dead and then nothing, straight into the epilouge. I would have liked a funeral or some sort of closing scene about the deaths.

(I howled continually through the book  :oops: Specially when *that* pair was killed - also trying to be ambiguous here - they were my favourites)

I was happy that one of my big theories was proved right though :D


Yeah - me too - that the both of them - so so sad.  The real wrench for me was the apparation silver one - oh I cried a lot for that - still brings tears to my eyes.  And the realisation of fate scene - oh that was terrible - I went right along for that ride. *Trying desperately not to spoil here*

But all those Harry/Hermione shippers must be crying themselves to sleep - as any sane person knew.  I actually saw one of them argue that Ron giving Hermione a bottle of perfume meant less than Harry giving her a book -  :shock: yeah - cause my husband wouldn't smash someone in the face if they were a friend and gave me perfume - books - no smashing  :lol:

I think maybe there was nothing that could be said at a funeral that we didn't already feel.  I think the continuation meant a lot - and the place they'd gone.  More than weeping - which we know they'll do.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Ash Redfern on 2007 July 21, 17:19:34
Quote from: "calalily"
But all those Harry/Hermione shippers must be crying themselves to sleep - as any sane person knew.


Sorry to disappoint, but I did not cry myself to sleep. I kind of rather shrugged about it and went on. ;)
And from the harry/hermione communities I drop in on, no one there has been crying either. Disappointed yes, but most have also been somewhat happy that it didn't happen after all.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 21, 17:46:39
Quote from: "Ash_Redfern"
Quote from: "calalily"
But all those Harry/Hermione shippers must be crying themselves to sleep - as any sane person knew.


Sorry to disappoint, but I did not cry myself to sleep. I kind of rather shrugged about it and went on. ;)
And from the harry/hermione communities I drop in on, no one there has been crying either. Disappointed yes, but most have also been somewhat happy that it didn't happen after all.


Oh I'm not talking about ordinary shippers - I'm talking about the ones that concocted elaborate essays on alchemy in Harry Potter to prove it beforehand, and did all amounts of bending to prove it true.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Aikane on 2007 July 22, 00:16:47
Like the one I'm friends with :P She has a pissy little message in her msn name this morning :P

Catalily, 'apparation silver one'? I'm being thick, that one went riiight over my head :)


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 22, 06:55:02
Quote from: "Aikane"
Like the one I'm friends with :P She has a pissy little message in her msn name this morning :P


Yeah - those ones.  I spent the night before DH reading their alchemy theories on Leaky - I have a good friend who is into alchemy and we were pming away on the subject, while laughing at the delusional shippers.  They had essays and everything  :lol:

Sorry the one I meant is the second personal one - involving the seaside - trying not to spoil for those readers.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Zazazu on 2007 July 23, 17:02:40
That was the one that made me cry non-stop and have to take a break. I still can't think about it (the seaside). With the two, I suspect it was part of her love of creating symmetry between the generations.

Loving the very very end with the comment made at the station. Trying to get away from the Snape-like predisposition, I take it.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Ieliminate on 2007 July 23, 18:06:23
I just finished the book. It was good, all except the epilogue. The epilogue was too goody-goody for me. It about made me cry, probably because it was the last one. I did have a good time shouting "OMG" during some parts.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: SparklePlenty on 2007 July 23, 18:25:49
Quote
But all those Harry/Hermione shippers must be crying themselves to sleep - as any sane person knew. I actually saw one of them argue that Ron giving Hermione a bottle of perfume meant less than Harry giving her a book -  yeah - cause my husband wouldn't smash someone in the face if they were a friend and gave me perfume - books - no smashing  


Calalily, I have seen that Ron and Hermione were an item since the Order of the Phoenix movie...she was all over Ron, worrying about his Feelings, and yelling at Harry for letting Ron get hurt....it was quite obvious after that. (I'm not spoiling anything, am I? My son is reading the book and won't tell me anything.)


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: calalily on 2007 July 24, 00:59:23
You're certainly not spoiling anything - it's been obvious since about book 2 that there is something more between the two of them.  

There's just confirmation of what's been obvious before that's all.

Quote
Loving the very very end with the comment made at the station.


Me too.

I think the funniest thing was Ron's remark about horcrux hunting in a mobile library.


Title: You have got to be kidding me...
Post by: Aikane on 2007 July 24, 06:15:01
Nah, the funniest bit was the Snape-shampoo comment made by Fred.  That was pure brilliance!